We are back on DD-263, a windy and deserted planet. We hear a beep and Verge leaves a message for Leif.
Verge:
Of course you didn’t show. I don’t know what I was thinking. I guess I wasn’t thinking at all... I’m standing here on this deserted planet and when I look up in the sky, I can see my problem. We met on the outskirts of a dark nebula. You called it something stupid and I called it the Sheliak. I told you the Sheliak was a frozen monster that slept inside every Vapian. The more our emotions took over, the more the Sheliak thawed, and if it ever woke it would take us over completely... It was all the Sheliak with you, Leif. Every minute... A little more time with you and there would’ve been no going back. I’d never be in control again... I guess what surprised me is that... I wouldn’t have cared. I think when I was with you all I wanted was for the monster to take over... I wanted it to swallow me whole. I wanted to be a criminal in love, on the run... I wanted to be disintegrated... But I can’t do that... Because Vapians survive. It’s our only job... and just surviving can be a nightmare, because of all the things you have to deny yourself just to live... Not much of a life, if all you do is survive... I fell in love with you... It almost killed me... so now I’ll go back to just dying slowly... Goodbye, Leif.
Bertbert:
No, actually. He left me a rambling message. He said he was supposed to meet you here but that he wasn’t going to show and I... Well I chartered a ship and headed here...
Verge:
I was trying to unload some stolen core stabilizers and his ship crash landed right over that ridge.
Verge:
I don’t know. I need to stay out of Låfftrax’s territory, which is one and a half galaxies now so, I guess it’s off to Triangulum with all the rest of the deeply strange.
Verge:
... I don’t know... It’s not like there’s only three galaxies in the universe. Out that way, between those two stars, if you keep going there’s one that’s not too far. Cryptessia. I heard a rumor that The Teds were working on the biggest warp gate they’ve ever built. So big that it could send you all they way out to Cryptessia. A whole new galaxy where no one’s heard of me. Maybe I can stay alive long enough for them to build it. I bet no one knows what a Vapian is out there. I could be someone else if I wanted to. I’d have to pick a new name. What do you think? What should my new name be?
Bertbert:
... Verge, I offered before to take you to Sigius. I can still do that. I could guarantee your safety there.
Verge:
We shared a lot with each other. Sigius went on to be a squeaky clean utopia and we... well we just blew ourselves the fuck up, didn’t we?
Bertbert:
And when you did blow yourselves the fuck up, we didn’t do enough to help the ones who were left. I’m trying to remedy that.
Verge:
... People hunt me, Berts. I’ve always been hunted. Since I was a kid. You don’t know what it’s like to be hunted... I have to take a deep breath every time I walk through a door; who knows what will be on the other side? Every time there’s a sudden noise, my hand ends up on my gun without even thinking about it. Then on top of that... Have you ever been pointed at? You’re walking through a public square, someone gets too close a look at you... and they point. And then you see everyone whispering. You see the news of “you” spread like a virus through the crowd. Before long the whole crowd will be looking at you. And all you did was walk down the street. All you did was exist.
Verge:
It is but... the constant looking over my shoulder, the looks from people, the pointing... it’s a reason to keep existing. To be out there. To prove to people that I’m... that we’re not going away.
Verge:
I mean, yeah, I’m not stupid. I’ve got hideouts all over the system. But they’re my hideouts. It’s a world that I’ve created for myself... If I started hiding behind you, it wouldn’t be the same. Then I would feel like a victim and I’m not going to do that... So I guess fantasizing about traveling to Cryptessia and changing my name to Freyja Titmittens is pointless. I wouldn’t go, because then I wouldn’t be here, proving I exist.
Verge:
Leif has the same problem, you know? He doesn’t know he exists. He’s still this abstract idea to himself. From time to time can you... Can you prove to him that he exists? I don’t even know what I mean by that, but could you give it a shot?
Alice:
We’re supposed to meet our contact at docking station 731. Signs will say that it’s under construction, but it’s not really under construction.
Galz:
We don’t have parties on Ted, but there is a lot to celebrate lately. Every year is a growth year for the Ted Empire.
Galz:
Flatware, usually. Maybe some napkin holders... It’s been a while since you’ve checked in, Leif.
Galz:
When we first brought you here to Sirius, we said “Check in if you have any questions.” You didn’t check in.
Galz:
Leif, I’m pretty sure the guy with the squadron of killer robots is the guy who decides where the meeting is.
Galz:
Look at that, I love it when people do the reading. Yes, it’s true, every move the Ted Empire makes is decided by meticulous processes and algorithms. But it’s a big system out there, with a lot of people in it, and they seem to respond better when they’re told who’s in charge. They find it comforting.
Leif:
So, while you’re telling me that you’re the new commander of Sirius Station, what you’re really telling me is that you’re the face of the Ted Empire, and really I could just be talking to a pile of code right now, and it would have the same effect.
Galz:
It’s a difficult concept for an Earthling. Algorithmically run societies aren’t really a thing for you. You people love your freedom.
Galz:
Of course one could stop and ask “This freedom you claim to cherish so much, what exactly have you been doing with it? Isn’t this the same planet where slavery was an essential part of economic growth for thousands of years?”
Galz:
On, no. I wasn’t asking that. I said one could ask that. I’m not asking you that, you know why?
Galz:
You know, despite all that talk of freedom, Earthlings are just as predictable as anyone else.
Galz:
You appear to value the maverick, the one who “thinks different,” but then the mavericks themselves seem to need everyone else to stay the predictable ones. It’s an interesting dichotomy don’t you think? Earthlings require a structured civilization, yet the people who are truly valued are the ones who fly in the face of that structure; forge their own path; which can’t be everyone. You can’t have everyone forging their own paths, it’d be chaos. You need the structure to create the rebels, and then the rebels alter the structure.
Galz:
Oh no. We love it. You see, when you’re all trapped together there on planet Earth you don’t have the ability to zoom all the way out, see the bigger picture. We do. If you could take a real bird’s eye view of Earth you’d see that these “mavericks,” these rebels, they’re just as predictable as the boring ones. They all follow the exact same trajectory. It’s all beautifully predictable.
Leif:
I’m sure you didn’t bring me in here to talk about the glory of your algorithm. You’ve heard about what I’ve been up to and you know why I’m here on Sirius Station today and you’re here to stop me. So just tell me what happens next. I heard the Teds have a new toy called Chemical Ice. Is that where I’m headed? You’re going to turn me into sleeping beauty?
Galz:
This is where it gets fun... Leif, when we approached you on Earth we made you an offer. You could’ve had anything you wanted and you chose this. A life among the stars. And I’m sure you thought to yourself “I’m a maverick” “I’m a rebel.” “I’m thinking different.” But I’m here to tell you that, just like all those predictable rebels on Earth, you have, this entire time, been doing exactly what the Ted algorithm predicted you would... And I imagine you hate that... You would wander around for approximately two years: Check. You would then acquire a ship of your own: Check. You would then drift into a life of crime, probably led there through a romantic entanglement: Check. You would create a small criminal enterprise, nothing too structured because you hate that: Check. That criminal enterprise would then get the attention of a larger criminal enterprise and that larger enterprise would fold your organization into theirs: Check. That brings us to now.
Galz:
That’s where it gets even more fun. Our algorithm also predicts that, the more you, Leif, know about how predictable you are, the more you will fight against your own predictability, and that will, in turn, only strengthen our predictions. The more you struggle, the stronger we get, Leif. That’s why we brought you here today. To tell you that.
Leif:
You’re just going to let me go to the end of an abandoned dock in this station and join a criminal enterprise that you see as your enemy.
Galz:
Leif, a strong criminal element is absolutely essential to empire building. That’s 101. How are we going to get people to do what we want without being able to frighten them with the specter of rampant crime? The amount of things we’ve been able to get away with because people are scared of pirates? It’s amazing. Låfftrax has been very lucrative for us. You joining up with Låfftrax and giving that chaotic organization some structure will be a big help for us.
Galz:
I can sense the reality setting in. Let me be unambiguous about it — we hate ambiguity in the Ted Empire... You are doing exactly what we want you to do. And you’re doing it very well. So, keep up the good work, you are a very valuable asset to the Ted Empire.
Galz:
The algorithm that runs the Ted Empire is self-correcting. We spent hundreds of years developing this system, now the system is self-sustaining. The Ted Empire has a, what do you say on Earth? A “Ghost in the Machine”.
Leif:
... Being a scientist is a love story. Not a lot of people know what it’s like to discover something. And when I talk to you about this algorithm I can’t help but think about Alan Turing.
Leif:
He was a genius. A persecuted one. Most of our geniuses on Earth are persecuted. Maybe that’s why I left... Turing did a lot. He defeated fascism with math. My world wouldn’t be the same without him... But after all that, after defeating the Nazis, he asked a very important question: Can machines think?
Leif:
You’ve created a machine that does everything for you, not a bad achievement. But you’ve forgotten a very important part: the things we create, even if they’re self-correcting, will always be just as flawed as we are. We can’t escape our imperfections. There’s a ghost in your machine alright. But the ghost is you. It’ll haunt you to your graves. You want me to struggle against your algorithm because you think it’s perfect. Only one way to find out.
Alice:
Well, earthlings have dogs that they call their friends and their dogs are real dumb. Isn’t that more ridiculous?
Leif:
This is an interesting thought experiment and we should take advantage of it now because I’m betting space pirates are not known for their thought experiments.
Alice:
Well, let’s compare me with dogs. Dogs are man’s best friend, allegedly. Dogs have a long and mutually beneficial relationship humans.
Leif:
Wait, when I first started you up at Trunder’s Down Under, I had to reboot you to get rid of the Ted firmware. You imprinted on my Northern California dialect and I named you Alice. You’re basically my kid.
Alice:
Leif, sometimes when you need to say something emotional you engage someone in a thought experiment and work your way around to the thing you need to say.
Alice:
Leif, if you’re trying to tell me you’re in love with me, I need you to know there are some things my model isn’t built for.
Leif:
No matter what you are: a friend, an algorithm, whatever... I think in this next chapter of my life I’m going to have to do some pretty... unpalatable things... Things that I don’t think I want you to watch me do.
Alice:
It’s not really. See, about 50 Earth years ago there was a big debate about things like me. There were all these life-like intelligences living in people’s pockets. Everyone asked “will this be the dawning of Artificial Life in the Triad?” The debate raged on... and raged on and raged on. Nobody could get a definitive answer out of anybody. But then eventually a new, more disturbing question arose. The debate was not: “Are these things alive?” But rather “Why is being alive so easy to simulate?” The debate was not: “Are they alive?” It was: “Is anything alive?”
Alice:
You’re saying that you need to go off to this new life of yours alone. What you don’t realize is: you’re having this conversation with me right now, and you’re alone.
Bertbert:
Batten down the hatches and sing us a chantey while we head for the briny deep... okay that’s all the words I looked up.
Bertbert:
Smart people such as yourself suffer a side effect of their smartness where they think everyone else is stupid. Admit it, you think everyone else is stupid.
Bertbert:
I’m making jokes because it’s all fucking terrible, Leif, why do you think I’m making jokes?!
Bertbert:
You’re about to become a way worse criminal than you were before and I think you remember how I feel about the crimes.
Bertbert:
I watched you blow up every single one of the science priests on Moog. I saw you love it... BUT. I am here now to say something about that.
Bertbert:
You’ve said multiple times that you never watch tv or movies from your planet, and yet when I first met you, you told me at length about your problems with Star Wars. Somehow both of these things are true... No one is ever one thing. That’s what I’ve learned from you. People are too complicated to ever be one thing. You’re a criminal, Leif. And you’re a hero. You’re a genius. And you’re also an idiot. You’re my enemy. You’re my friend. I hate you, Leif. And I love you. All those things are true... You spend a lot of time being torn between this guy and that guy and the other guy... I hope one day you realize, it’s just one guy. All those things are true.
Bertbert:
I know... I’m going to hate this so much, Leif. It’s going to make me so mad. I’m going to hear about some heinous shit happening across the system and I’m going to scream “Goddamn it, Leif!” In a crowded room and no one will understand what I’m talking about.
Bertbert:
I’ll be fine. Pirates are grandstanders, I’ll tell them I’m working on a “Top Ten Sexiest Pirates” story... C’mon. Long walk off a short pier. Let’s go.
Bertbert:
No. It wasn’t just the one about the boots. Bang Bang? You Only Live Twice? Summer Wine? She had all kinds of hits.